Audio format Any YT creator that’s been around for a minute has their detractors, it’s the name of the social media game. Before you decide to spend time, energy and money on them, it’s a good idea to sort of look beneath the hood and kick the tires before jumping on the bandwagon.
What follows is a “cult checklist” because if you decide to back/follow a creator it can result in you being inducted into what amounts to a cult.
Putting things out there for public consumption whether it be videos or blog posts, there should be an overall theme for people to resonate with. If it’s murky, creators should be open to questions. Heck, they should be open for questions anyway - it’s the only way to enter into civil discourse. If questioning isn’t allowed, run away as fast as you can.
If YT creators are lucky enough to be monetized, take a moment to calculate just how much they may be pulling in. Some just have ad revenue while others also have memberships, sometimes different tiers of membership. If they also push and push for tips/donations, lock your wallet up tight. If they straight up ask the viewers to pay for things like a “producer fund,” I have questions. Those questions multiply if there are multiple GoFundMes and Amazon lists being shared.
Vague references to “people out to get them” is a huge warning sign. Keep in mind that we see the world how WE are rather than how it actually is. Be wary of buying into their world view.
For whatever reason, many creators do have videos/articles/tweets from detractors. Don’t be quick to dismiss them out of hand.
A leader also uses his co-leaders to make this point. While they may pretend to entertain notions of being fallible to the public and even within the group, a deeper probing will lead to the fact that they won’t truly admit to not being right.
Again, co-leaders and those that head up his “tribe” (perhaps including moderators on YT) are used by a leader to keep the community at large in the dark while also pretending to pander to their wants & needs. Dissention may be sown to keep the group a little off balance for easier manipulation. This also makes it easier for the leader to keep an iron grip on "truth" and disways folks from looking deeper.
If you find yourself defending the leader/creator and have no real idea why except for “well he’s a nice person and people are mean” you might just be under the influence of a cult leader. Take a step back!
Ditto - it’s called a “persecution complex” and the leader/co-leaders will feed into this while also claiming they don’t want drama.
I think this is covered in 7 in that followers seem to somehow feel compelled to protect leadership. While it feels normal & natural, it’s anything but. A red flag should pop up if you find yourself parroting leaderships’ words.
Oh yes, justification is a big one. It’s okay for leadership to say/be/do something but not for others, especially detractors.
People with more than two brain cells to rub together will eventually get wise to the cult & its leaders. They will think “how could I have been so deluded?” They will feel shame and embarrassment. This is not only natural, it's also very understandable. Many detractors will accept you if you reach out. These detractors didn’t detract just to be dramatic bullies, they were attempting to warn others as best they could. They are the strongest amongst those that have escaped the cult and want nothing more than to stand vanguard against the cult in order to protect more vulnerable targets.
Cult leaders are usually narcissists
While it can be argued that many/most YT creators have narcissistic tendencies, if they’re not self-aware it can become a problem. Especially for those that become entrenched in their communities. So before you decide to dive into any YT community, think about the following (if the aforementioned cult checklist didn’t do it for you).
A brief list of narcissistic traits:
Being overly boastful, exaggerating one’s own achievements
Pretending to be superior to others
Lack of empathy for others
Looking down on others as inferior
Monopolizing conversations
Impatient, angry, unhappy, depressed or has mood swings when criticized
Easily disappointed when expected importance is not given
Always craves for “the best” in everything
Has a very fragile self-esteem
Narcissistic personality disorder involves a pattern of self-centered, arrogant thinking and behavior, a lack of empathy and consideration for other people, and an excessive need for admiration. Others often describe people with NPD as cocky, manipulative, selfish, patronizing, and demanding.
When deciding whether to follow YT creator, you probably aren’t going to be looking at any sort of intimate relationship so your inner alarm system may be delayed or not go off until those around you become uneasy. It can be quite insidious. You may think it’s just you. You tend to go along to get along or to protect the community at large. You could find yourself behaving in ways that are actually contrary to who you are. It’s okay - they make a living fooling people. Consider the following:
Dealing with a narcissist: Don’t fall for the fantasy (Link)
Narcissists can be very magnetic and charming. They are very good at creating a fantastical, flattering self-image that draws us in. We’re attracted to their apparent confidence and lofty dreams—and the shakier our own self-esteem, the more seductive the allure. It’s easy to get caught up in their web, thinking that they will fulfill our longing to feel more important, more alive. But it’s just a fantasy, and a costly one at that.
Your needs won’t be fulfilled (or even recognized). It’s important to remember that narcissists aren’t looking for partners; they’re looking for obedient admirers. Your sole value to the narcissist is as someone who can tell them how great they are to prop up their insatiable ego. Your desires and feelings don’t count.
Look at the way the narcissist treats others. If the narcissist lies, manipulates, hurts, and disrespects others, he or she will eventually treat you the same way. Don’t fall for the fantasy that you’re different and will be spared.
Take off the rose-colored glasses. It’s important to see the narcissist in your life for who they really are, not who you want them to be. Stop making excuses for bad behavior or minimizing the hurt it’s causing you. Denial will not make it go away. The reality is that narcissists are very resistant to change, so the true question you must ask yourself is whether you can live with this indefinitely.
Don’t beat yourself up too much - it really isn’t you, it’s them. You got caught up, it happens. What matters now is how you move forward. And you’ve learned some valuable lessons - congrats!!
Just a little thing I recently discovered that I think that describes the blind believers of Andy’s crap & enable him to keep doing it: