A couple of weeks ago I had no idea who Colleen Ballinger aka Miranda Sings was. Usually, unless Swoop does a documentary, I don't know/care about what family vloggers, the beauty community and/or drama/commentary channels are doing on YouTube. However, Colleen's exploits have set off a variety of content creators so I started tuning in.
Andy is the host of Popcorned Planet YouTube channel who is supposedly serving "pop culture justice" (no, it's not an actual thing). He can be engaging and charismatic until you get a peek beneath his mask. Then you see what a charlatan he is and how much sexual innuendo is sprinkled throughout his live streams/videos. From his coverage of Britney Spears and Gabby Petito he started gaining a following of youngish/middle aged women who have been abused in a variety of ways. A veritable smorgasbord for a creepy pervert. Allegedly, IMO.
Colleen Ballinger is a children's entertainer using a character called Miranda Sings. She's found quite a bit of success and a following of pre-teen kids. She makes herself available via Discord and engages in private chat groups with select young people. These kids are big fans and are excited to talk to her. Her shows in themselves are problematic enough, liberally sprinkled with sexual innuendo, but she seems to take it many, many steps too far. A former fan, Adam McIntyre, spoke out in 2020 and was practically run off the internet by Colleen and her cohorts/fans. Now others are speaking up and it looks like a reckoning will be happening as soon as she quits ignoring the situation.
What strikes me are the similarities between Colleen Bellinger's and Andy Signore's antics:
Secret chats: CHECK
Focusing on vulnerable people: CHECK
Rallying community attack dogs: CHECK
Forcing silence: CHECK
Co-host/audience that covers/excuses horrid behavior: CHECK
Taking advantage of a power imbalance: CHECK
Confession through projection (and/or DARVO): CHECK
Ownership of people but not of their own behavior: CHECK
Overinflated egos and a sense of entitlement: CHECK
Lack of self-awareness or self-reflection: CHECK
Victim blaming: CHECK
- Completely ignores the idea of "consent:" CHECK
Gets others to spy/do their dirty work: CHECK
- Being shady about charity donations: CHECK
- Liberal use of sexual innuendos: CHECK
I'm a mom of one young adult son and I find Collen's behavior just about as abhorrent as I find Andy's. The irony of him doing a stream on Colleen shows how non-self aware he is. To be fair, I have not subjected myself to his take on the situation but the whole idea just oozes of hypocrisy, IMO.
Both focus on a specific audience, Colleen's being arguably more problematic than Andy's. However, both use their power imbalance to target vulnerable people. It seems that Colleen has been inappropriate with children for years while Andy prefers damaged women. Both are populations that should be protected at all costs. And the average person does, but not these two.
They build their victims (aka "love bombing" up via "secret" chats/private chats in order to take advantage of them. From the above linked article from the Cleveland Clinic:
What is love bombing?
Love bombing is a form of psychological and emotional abuse that involves a person going above and beyond for you in an effort to manipulate you into a relationship with them. It looks different for every person, but it usually involves some form of excessive flattery and praise...
If the victims fight back, they are berated and belittled. Both tend to send friends/community members after them while pretending ignorance/innocence.
More from the Cleveland Clinic:
[Love bombing is] usually driven by a person’s insecurities, inability to trust and dependence on other people. Although anyone can do it, love bombing is most often associated with people who have an anxious or insecure attachment style or narcissistic personality disorder (NPD). People can also pick up on this behavior by learning it from their parents (like passive-aggression) or from past abusive relationships. It can also be a side effect of unresolved childhood trauma (though, this isn’t always the case).
“If you turn down advances from a person who’s love bombing you or they feel you’re not responding to their needs, they might threaten or berate you,” explains Dr. Tiani. “They want that constant reassurance that they’re loved and worthy and this stems from their underlying insecurities.”
If they do, indeed, suffer from some sort of mental defect, they need help. That does not mean that I don't find both reprehensible. They are both grown ass adults with plenty of evidence in front of them to realize something ain't right. And the fact that Colleen is being called out by some bigger content creators gives me hope that the same will one day happen with Andy.